The publisher fires callbacks via SubscriptionCallbackWorkItem::call(), which read
the subscriber's _last_generation (and called updated(), which reads it again) to
decide whether to schedule the work item. That made the subscriber's read cursor a
cross-thread field - publisher reads it while the subscriber writes it in copy() -
which TSan flagged and which we had wrapped in an atomic.
Instead, hand the publishing node's generation into call() and let the callback keep
its own _last_scheduled_generation cursor for the count gate (_required_updates).
call() runs under the node lock, so that cursor is only ever touched there and is
serialized - no atomic needed, and using the real generation (not a plain counter)
means a coalesced/missed call() does not drift the batch. The redundant updated()
generation check is dropped (call() only runs right after a publish, so it is always
true); the interval gate (_last_update / _interval_us) is kept unchanged.
With the publisher no longer reading it, _last_generation reverts to a plain unsigned
(subscriber-thread only). Behaviour is unchanged: the count and interval throttles
fire at the same rates (verified via work_queue status - gyro_fft 62.5 Hz,
flight_mode_manager 50 Hz) and TSan stays clean.
* refactor(uORB): out-line PublicationBase/Subscription methods to save flash
Move the type-independent PublicationBase::advertise()/publish() and
Subscription::copy()/update() bodies out of the headers into
Publication.cpp / Subscription.cpp, leaving only declarations inline.
PX4 links with bfd ld (no identical-code folding) and without LTO, so
these header-inline methods were emitted per translation unit: GCC both
.isra-cloned them (~39 publish, 25 advertise, 17 copy, 12 update copies)
and fully inlined them into many callers. Out-lining collapses all of
that to a single shared definition each.
This is the out-of-line follow-up to #27526, which hoisted advertise/
publish from the Publication<T> template into the non-template
PublicationBase but kept them inline in the header. The methods were
already emitted as separate clones, so callers already pay a bl and the
publish/read hot paths are unchanged -- this is pure code motion.
Saves 10.4 KB .text on auterion_fmu-v6x (1,949,568 -> 1,939,168).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
* refactor(uORB): out-line SubscriptionCallback register/unregister to save flash
Move SubscriptionCallback::registerCallback()/unregisterCallback() out of the
header into a new SubscriptionCallback.cpp. Like the Publication/Subscription
methods, these were emitted per translation unit (PX4 links with bfd ld, no
ICF, no LTO): GCC .isra-cloned them and inlined them into every WorkItem-based
subscriber's setup path.
registerCallback() runs only at subscription/callback setup (cold path), so
out-lining is pure code motion with no hot-path change.
Saves 4.9 KB .text on auterion_fmu-v6x (1,939,168 -> 1,934,128).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
* refactor(uORB): out-line remaining Subscription methods to save flash
Extends this PR's pattern to the rest of Subscription: move the type-independent methods still defined in the header (constructors, destructor, copy/move assignment, updated(), advertised()) into Subscription.cpp so they are emitted once instead of inlined into every translation unit.
updated()/advertised() inline the Manager::updates_available / is_advertised (DeviceNode) chain, and the constructors were inlined at every subscription site, so most of the remaining duplication lived there. ~9.4 KB .text saved on ark_fmu-v6x_default.
---------
Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Co-authored-by: Jacob Dahl <dahl.jakejacob@gmail.com>
Proxy all calls to the DeviceNode through Manager;
- This hides the DeviceNode from publishers and subscribers
- Manager can be made an interface class between user and kernel spaces in protected build
- This doesn't increase code size or harm the performance on flat build
Signed-off-by: Jukka Laitinen <jukkax@ssrc.tii.ae>