Commit Graph
6 Commits
Author SHA1 Message Date
Jacob Dahl c9f5442402 feat(sensors): classify sensors independently of bus topology (#28352)
* feat(sensors): decouple sensor internal/external classification from the bus

A sensor's internal/external classification was derived from its bus
(px4_i2c_bus_external / px4_spi_bus_external), but a bus is a wire: one bus
routinely serves both chips soldered on the FC and a pinned-out connector, and
any onboard sensor on such a shared bus was classified external. That hands an
onboard mag an operator-settable rotation instead of the board rotation, feeds
an onboard baro's self-heated die temperature into air density as if it were
ambient, and inverts the 75/50 default priority. FMU-v6C and AirBrainH743
worked around it with hand-rolled device_id whitelists behind
BOARD_OVERRIDE_I2C_DEVICE_EXTERNAL; FMU-v6XRT's second onboard baro was simply
misclassified.

Classify the device instead of the bus: drivers publish is_external in
sensor_accel/gyro/mag/baro, derived from the device id by default and
overridden by the new -O start flag ("onboard") for onboard sensors that share
a bus with an external connector. -I/-X stay pure bus probe filters.

The question "is this sensor external" had four answers. It now has one, with
a single override point:

  -O -> I2CSPIDriverConfig::external -> Device::set_external() and the
        PX4* wrappers -> is_external in the sensor topic

px4_i2c_device_external() was px4_i2c_bus_external() with a device id decode in
front, and calibration::DeviceExternal() forwarded to device_is_external();
both are gone. Device::external() stops being a bus query: it is non-virtual,
defaults to device_is_external(), and takes the declared value through
set_external(), so the five I2C/SPI overrides that used to answer it from the
bus are deleted and cannot diverge again. device::I2C and device::SPI set it
from the config, so every driver built on the bus framework follows -O without
doing anything. px4_i2c_bus_external() and px4_spi_bus_external() survive as
what they honestly are - bus predicates - reachable only through the fallback.

-O is opt-in per driver (BusCLIArguments::support_onboard), the same way -k is:
a flag that every driver advertised but only a handful honoured would be a
silent no-op on the rest. This also drops the special case for the mcp23009 and
mcp23017 GPIO expanders, which use -O for their output state and simply do not
opt in.

sensor_gyro_fifo carries is_external too. VehicleAngularVelocity prefers the
FIFO topic for any IMU that publishes one, so without it the rate controller
would take its rotation from the bus while VehicleIMU took it from the topic -
the same chip, two classifications.

The BOARD_OVERRIDE_I2C_DEVICE_EXTERNAL hook is removed along with both board
implementations, replaced by -O on the affected rc.board_sensors lines.
FMU-v5x, MR-CANHUBK3, KakuteF7, NXT-Dual and MicoAir H743-Lite each start an
onboard barometer on an external bus and get the flag as well.

Assisted-by: Claude:claude-fable-5, Claude:claude-opus-5[1m]
Signed-off-by: Jacob Dahl <dahl.jakejacob@gmail.com>

* feat(sensors): treat shared buses as first-class topology

A boolean internal/external flag cannot describe a bus that carries both
hard-mounted chips and a connector. -O was an opt-in override for that
case, so most drivers silently ignored it and classification still
followed the bus.

Declare Internal / External / Shared on the bus, probe External and
Shared, and classify each sensor from -I/-s vs -X/-S.

Signed-off-by: Jacob Dahl <dahl.jakejacob@gmail.com>

* fix(ci): drop stale ITCM symbols and clang-tidy errors

ITCM lists still named calibration::DeviceExternal and
px4_spi_bus_external after both were removed. The host test stubs
forwarded varargs in a way the analyzer rejected, and stripped I2C
headers kept extra trailing newlines.

Signed-off-by: Jacob Dahl <dahl.jakejacob@gmail.com>

* fix(sensors): inline device_is_external into the header

Reaching it through drivers__device pulled the kernel-only library into
the userspace image of a protected build; giving it a library of its own
put an archive referencing px4_i2c_buses/px4_spi_buses after the board
library that defines them. Inlining sidesteps both.

* fix(sensors): compile tcbp001ta and probe canhubk3 GPS mag

tcbp001ta is not an I2CSPIDriver, so config.external does not exist; it
only ever starts on internal SPI. -X on canhubk3 I2C2 never ran because
that bus is Internal.

Signed-off-by: Jacob Dahl <dahl.jakejacob@gmail.com>

---------

Signed-off-by: Jacob Dahl <dahl.jakejacob@gmail.com>
2026-08-28 21:14:13 -06:00
Julian Oes 8080ca966a boards/platform: remove confusing override
This removes the odd px4_i2c_bus_external override which was confusing
me and lead to odd and inconsistent results.

The function is now only available with an int as the argument.
2022-09-23 20:54:08 +12:00
Daniel Agar a47895e809 [DO NOT MERGE] px4_i2c_device_external hacks 2022-09-20 10:31:26 +12:00
Daniel Agar 7b7b7acd36 i2c_spi_buses: respect CONFIG_I2C and CONFIG_SPI
- bmp280, dps310, and ms5611 barometers support boards without I2C
2021-11-15 15:57:33 -05:00
Beat Küng 787f9c1213 i2c: use board-specific bus numbering for '-X -b <bus>' CLI
As boards don't have their external buses labeled consistently, it was not
useful to use an abstraction.
2020-09-03 15:32:35 -04:00
Beat Küng 06712450a7 i2c+spi: add module base class and bus iterators 2020-03-10 10:11:43 -04:00